Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Idol Update 02/20 - Top 12 Females...

The Women, I hope they are better! I hope I have time to watch the whole show...

Kristie Lee Cook - She's sick! Whatever...she was pretty boring...i think she's safe no matter what, but this was not a good first performance. After the men, this isn't a good thing. Apparently everyone is sick...GREAT....

Joann - Not bad....MAYBE SHE'S SICK...i like how she said everyone expects her to be this super diva because she's a big woman...Simon is being harsh, he's always grouchy when there is a bunch of bad people in a row.

Alaine - Not bad at all. Vocals are really good, and she's got the crowd going and she doesn't seem afraid. BTW, David (the first David who was nervous) is bizarre, look at how he's staring and whoever is singing. Positively stalkerish....

Amanda - I don't like how she's singing. It's mumbling...i'm not getting why she arranged the song to totally overshadow her vocals. On the plus side its modern and interesting. Eh...very gimmicky...

Amy -ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

Brooke - AGAIN with this song. It's ok, her vocals are really very so-so. Wow, for the second year in a row we have started off the Top 24 super super shaky.

No more time today...will pick up tommorrow...

Watched it real quick this morning and to be honest, it was about as underwhelming as the men, mainly because i think it came after the men so I just wanted the woman to be so good to make up for them. I though Ramele was very good, she sang really well and unlike some of the other people, she didn't try to blast through the song.

I still think we get better results from this year than last year. I think this week will serve as a wake me up and we'll get a lot better results next week. I'll remain optimistic..

JUAN

2 comments:

planetmaria said...

Wow, the girls are BOOORING. Shocking. I didn't expect this.

Even more shocking - I actually liked Amanda the rocker nurse, and I was NOT a fan. That's a really old blues song she sang. great for her voice, I thought.

Agree that Alaina was surprisingly good.

I also enjoyed Alexandrea, with "Spinning Wheel". And damn, Asia'H is pulling out Dusty Springfield!!!
She sounds hoarse, though.

more later.
maria

planetmaria said...

I don't know yet if this year's crop is any better or worse than previous years. Ryan Seacrest repeating "BEST TOP 24 EVER!!" doesn't make it so.

I'm also keeping fingers crossed for a better showing next week.

Maria