Ok, the women! Let's go...
Carly - Pretty good, not excited by Heart. Simon gives her his endorsement, which is important. I don't think she's as good as he does, but we'll see. Good start to the show, ok for the girls is a level above ok for the guys.
Syesha - I like her but I don't think she's going to far. She's singing Mr. Jones. i think she is real good. However, it's not earth shattering, and I'm not sure it keeps her in. I hope so. Great vocal, not that exciting a performance. They (the judges) didn't feel it at all.
Brooke - She's singing You're so Vain. I hate it. I don't like this song, it's not particularly hard to sing the way she is singing, it's just so vanilla and painful. Just stop... Wow, Simon loved it. I like her, so i'll accept this but I'm not in agreement.
Ramiele - She has a real nice tone to her voice. It's not the voice you'd expect to come out of that body. Hey, i thought this was good. The freaking You're so Vain is good and the judges don't like her. Ugh... THey seem to like her just not tonight...FINE..... She's really young, she talks like we know what she is talking about, just rambling.
Kristie - She says america will be surprised to know she's a tomboy. Yes, possibly we'd be surprised if we didn't know you were a cagefighter already!! She's not bad, it's not the greatest song choice. She may just not be as good as I thought. I really think she's the best looking contestant they have ever had. Judges seem to agree, good not great. I don't like the excuse making.
Amanda - I predict she'll sing a rock song in the same tone as she has before. She reads, exciting. I like the song choice. I don't like her hair, makes her look fat. (If you are looking you know what I mean.) It's not a good vocal at all. This show's them is good, but nowhere close to very good. This basically continues that.
Watched the rest of the show but not as closely as I had the baby. Alaina and Kady are so vanilla that i don't really think I can tell them apart. Both were awful and Hopelessly Devoted is NOT what I think of as the 70's. Asiah at the end totally tried for too much. That song was too much for her voice.
The judges were kind of spot on tonight. Very shaky. The Top 24 theme shows are killing the contestants. I don't think their will be any surprises tommorrow, there are so many people who could go and not make a ripple, i'm confident none of the favorites have anything to worry about.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
*YAWN*...this show seems to be dragging tonight. Good thing I'm multitasking.
They were all easily forgettable. Song choices were pretty decent, but most girls couldn't pull it off.
Carly was ok. Think she can do a lot better. Her voice kind of reminds me of Alison Moyet.
The second girl, can't think of her name...liked her from the top 24 -- one of the better ones tonight.
Brooke's "You're so vain" was the most solid, in-tune, natural performances.
Eeek, Rocker girl was just off-key all over the place. Her hair is scary.
Kady Malloy's performance was awkward, out of tune.
Asia'ah wasn't that great. Have to agree with Simon there, although I liked her in the top 24.
Most seemed unnatural and lost. They all need to step it up to continue. -SN
I think we can all agree by now that this is NOT "the best top 24 EVER"!!
Yeesh.
Post a Comment