Top 10 Thoughts...

Not a bad show...one of those shows were some of the judge's comments stuck me as odd. Funny so see Randy with an agenda, does he not realize america listens to Simon, and only Simon?

Ramiele - I liked it. She's getting killed in some circles for not being as creative as some of the others, but this is American Idol. All of a sudden obscure songs are better? Let's face it, she sang ALONE, which Carrie killed years ago, and if you are not ok, Simon will kill you. he did not kill her. So she stays...

Kristie - Judges confused me on this. What was so great about it? Maybe i attach this song to obnoxious misplaced patriotism (this strikes me as something you play at a pro-war rally), but maybe that's just me. Hate the song, the vocals were eh, and i didn't get why it was praised. i still think she might be bottom three.

Michael Johns - is it ok to sing TWO songs? He did sing two songs, right? Great performance though, brought it home so strong. Went from floating to being in a real solid place. Ramiele, please note Michael Johns and approach accordingly.

David Cook - WHOA...WHOA...WHOA. Awesome, original, great vocals. One of my favorite contestants every if this keeps up. If you can't find something you want to sing, take something and make it your own. WHOA...

David Archulete - This blew. It was awful. Terrible song choice, he didn't sing well. I agree with Simon, he's being overcoached. A week where he just takes a known song and blows it out would do him wonders. And I don't doubt it's coming.

Syesha - I remember i thought she sang real well. I also don't remember what she sang. At all. Not even a little. I don't feel that's a good sign. I remember Randy did some over the top praise that makes me hate the person singing, like he did with David A and Carly before at different points (You are the dark horse now! Dark Horse for what? Syesha has no chance to win at all, sorry..) I think she could be bottom three.

Carly - Wow, a mess. I didn't like it at all. Didn't show off her vocals, just wasn't that good. I think she easily stays, because she has a lot of fans, and they are scared now and voting. But really not that good.

Chikezie - Too boring, too old fashioned, not good for someone so on the bubble. May go home..

Jason Castro -ZZZZZZZ, at least he understood the criticism. Could be surprise bottom three. No chance to go home, but seriously, he needs to step up.

Brooke White - Boring Boring Boring. She looked real nice, and she seems to be popular, but I didn't get the performance. She has a style she is repeating week to week, but I'm not sure I love it.

If I had to guess, I'd say bottom three is Syesha, Kristie and Chikezie with Chikezie going home.

Kimberly Locke performs tonight I believe.

JUAN